Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kent's avatar

The USN reports that the USS Lincoln flew over 10,000 sorties and 1.5mm lbs of ordnance. The US abandoned its land bases early on, both air bases and the fleet HQ in Bahrain. So I think the carrier bore more of the weight of the bombing campaign, which admittedly wasn't that effective against weapons hidden underground.

I think what we can learn from the Iranian War is that land bases are easy targets because they are large and stationary. Everyone has Google Earth. Iran even has an intelligence satellite from China. Drones and missiles will find them. Air force planes may be valuable weapons in the air, but they are sitting ducks on the ground. So is their jet fuel. Naval bases fare no better, which means warship resupply is much longer. A nuclear flattop still needs jet fuel and food. The threat of missile attacks kept the US fleet far from the Strait, meaning its sorties were longer and required more fuel.

The conclusion: don't build big, expensive targets on land or sea. They are too precious to risk. Spread your risk into mobile, hard to find weapons that require little supply.

Another conclusion is that the US military is falling apart. They have 10 carriers, plus one going into mothball status. At least half sit in ports being repaired for years, even during war. The US isn't willing to risk the loss of personnel (soldiers, airmen, or seamen), so it must rely on extremely expensive long-range missiles. They refuse to adapt; they've disbanded the battalion that was learning drone warfare in and from Ukraine. Their giant budget pays for obsolete weapons and corruption (contracts to companies affiliated with Trump's sons). Leadership competence is irrelevant; anyone may and will be fired under suspicion of being insufficiently loyal to the administration. And above all, they never disclose or acknowledge that they were routed in Iran. Therefore, they will not learn or correct.

Ziggy's avatar

Is the lesson from the Iran war that navies are useless? Maybe. Or maybe the lesson is that no military has ever won a war 100% from the air. Or maybe both are true.

btw, I think that the US uniformed military knows that airpower has its limits. The problem: its civilian overseers do not. From a US politician's standpoint, airpower is ideal--plenty of overseas boom, with few US casualties. But this only makes political sense when the US can declare victory and go home, which it doesn't have a good recent record on.

11 more comments...

Ready for more?